Rob BontaDavid O. CarterKenneth KaoJames BoasbergDonald TrumpTrump administrationJustice DepartmentTrump AdministrationU.S. Supreme CourtCalifornia

Supreme Court rejects Trump administration push to set aside thousands of California mail ballots; judge found lists flawed, many wrongly listed as noncitizens

The Supreme Court on Monday rejected the Trump administration's attempt to set aside thousands of California mail ballots, ruling that the lists of suspected noncitizens were flawed. The decision comes just before the midterm elections, with concerns over potential disenfranchisement of voters.

Reuters Reuters+1 source3 November 2026 · 02:28 UTC
Media in this story
CuriousCats Full Story

The Supreme Court's ruling on November 2, 2026, prevents the Trump administration from segregating mail ballots in California, impacting over 20,000 voters flagged as likely noncitizens.12

U.S. District Judge James Boasberg criticized the administration's lists as flawed, stating, "California may decide for itself what procedures to use for verifying the citizenship of registered voters."

The court emphasized that the Executive Branch lacks authority to impose its procedures unilaterally.45

The decision arrives just before crucial midterm elections, raising fears of disenfranchisement.

A district judge warned that the administration's demands could "wreak havoc" on the electoral process, undermining trust in democracy.910

California Attorney General Rob Bonta described the appeal as desperate, asserting it undermines elections and the rule of law.

The administration's push faced significant legal challenges, with lower courts siding with California officials.

Judge David O. Carter stated, "If the Executive can discount votes and threaten an ongoing election due to unproven allegations, then our democracy is in danger."

The ruling reflects a broader trend of judicial resistance to the administration's election-related initiatives, as seen in previous cases where the court sided against Trump's efforts to restrict mail ballots nationwide.67

The high court's decision not only protects the integrity of California's elections but also reinforces the principle that states govern their electoral processes.

Key Insight
“The ruling came a day before the midterm elections, with Chief Judge James Boasberg writing that the Executive Branch likely violated the Elections Clause. A Justice Department attorney acknowledged a high error rate in the list, while California officials said segregating the ballots now would be logistically impossible.”
Supreme Court rejects Trump request for California to set aside ballots from alleged noncitizens
CuriousCats Shorts-list
Supreme Court rejects Trump request for California to set aside ballots from alleged noncitizens
CuriousCats studied:
1
ReutersReuters
“A US judge ordered the Trump administration on Monday to stop demanding that California election officials segregate ballots cast by people on its lists of suspected noncitizens.”
Reuters →
2
The HinduThe Hindu
“The Supreme Court on Monday (November 2, 2026) rejected a push for California to set aside thousands of mail ballots from people President Donald Trump's administration claims are non-citizens, a decision that comes on the eve of the pivotal midterm elections.”
The Hindu →
Ask CuriousCats
Who is Chief Judge James Boasberg?
What prompted the Trump administration's push?
Why were some ballots listed as noncitizens?
Are other states facing similar voter verification issues?
How does this ruling compare to past election controversies?
Get your CIA-level briefing,
in real time.
CuriousCats monitors the internet every minute for you and brings you the most personalized brief of videos, social media posts, news and more.
Download the App
If you liked this, you’ll love your CuriousCats brief.
News, videos, opinions and more — without the noise.
Get CuriousCats