Donald TrumpStephen MillerRand PaulMarlin StutzmanAssociated Press

Trump promotes Stephen Miller to White House chief of staff after midterm loss; critics call him 'the most broken man'

After a disappointing midterm election, President Trump promoted Stephen Miller to White House chief of staff, despite widespread criticism labeling him 'the most broken man.' Critics argue Miller's hard-line immigration policies contributed to the GOP's losses and question his ability to foster productive congressional relations.

The Hill The Hill9 November 2026 · 19:24 UTC
Media in this story
CuriousCats Full Story

After a significant midterm loss, President Trump has promoted Stephen Miller to White House chief of staff, a move that has drawn sharp criticism from both Democrats and Republicans.45

Critics argue that Miller, who has been a key architect of the administration's hard-line immigration policies, is emblematic of the dysfunction within the White House. “He decides to hire the most broken man to continue to run the most dysfunctional White House we’ve seen,” said one critic, highlighting concerns over Miller's impact on American society and culture.

Indiana Republican Congressman Marlin Stutzman, who previously called for Miller's dismissal, noted that the administration's deportation tactics have become a political liability. “Miller should be fired,” he stated, emphasizing the need for a more effective approach to governance.3

The promotion raises questions about Trump's strategy moving forward, as many believe that doubling down on controversial figures like Miller may alienate voters further. “Why appoint this man to White House chief of staff if you want to have a productive relationship with Congress?” asked another critic, underscoring the potential challenges ahead for the administration.

As Miller steps into his new role, the implications of his leadership will be closely watched, particularly in light of the recent electoral setbacks for the GOP.

Key Insight
“The Associated Press found strikes linked to Miller killed fishermen, laborers, and drivers, not just cartel leaders, many without arrest or charges. Republican Rep. Marlin Stutzman and Sen. Rand Paul also raised concerns about the appointment's political and legal implications.”
Enten unpacks Trump's 'tone deaf' Stephen Miller pick
CuriousCats Shorts-list
Enten unpacks Trump's 'tone deaf' Stephen Miller pick
Trump says his deportation policy 'might have been too tough' for voters
CuriousCats Shorts-list
Trump says his deportation policy 'might have been too tough' for voters
CuriousCats studied:
1
The HillThe Hill
“After that blue tsunami hit the Republicans in the midterms, you might expect a president to reassess, but President Trump’s lesson from all of this seems to be that it’s time to double down. He chose to promote one of the people most closely associated with the agenda voters just rejected.”
The Hill →
Ask CuriousCats
What led to Trump's promotion of Miller?
Why are critics concerned about Miller's appointment?
How did the AP investigations impact public perception?
Are there similar controversies surrounding other staff appointments?
How does Miller's strategy compare with previous administrations?
Get your CIA-level briefing,
in real time.
CuriousCats monitors the internet every minute for you and brings you the most personalized brief of videos, social media posts, news and more.
Download the App
Liked the depth here?
Get the full internet briefed for you any time of the day.
Get CuriousCats