- Reformative training or imprisonment should be the default sentences for young offenders convicted of scams and scam-enabling offences, according to the proposed Sentencing (Scams) Bill introduced by the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) on Nov 3.
- The Bill states that offenders aged 21 or below at the time of the offence should be sentenced to reformative training or imprisonment as primary options, unless there are exceptional circumstances.
- The High Court ruling on Sep 10 stated that reformative training or imprisonment should not be the default sentence for young offenders who commit scam-enabling offences, allowing four appeals and replacing sentences with probation.
- Senior Minister K Shanmugam emphasized the need to reinforce a deterrence approach in sentencing, arguing that the High Court's rationale contradicts established sentencing guidelines.
- The High Court ruling involved the appeals of Mohamed Erzan Taib Zohri and six others, all of whom were involved in scam-related offences, with six of the seven offenders being under the age of 21.
- Scams remain a significant issue in Singapore, with the police investigating over 1,000 youths in connection with scam reports in 2025, and a 37% increase in youths committing cheating and related offences from 2024 to 2025.
- The MHA noted that youths involved in scams were largely acting as mules, facilitating the scams by providing bank accounts or credentials.

Singapore's Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) has introduced the Sentencing (Scams) Bill, which aims to make reformative training or imprisonment the default sentences for young offenders convicted of scams and scam-enabling offences. This legislative move follows a High Court ruling that questioned the appropriateness of such sentences for young offenders.12345891011
The Bill, presented for the first reading in parliament on November 3, reflects the government's recognition of the escalating scam crisis, with over 1,000 youths investigated in 2025 alone. The MHA reported a 37% increase in youth involvement in cheating and related offences, rising from 814 in 2024 to 1,114 in 2025. Many of these youths acted as mules, facilitating scams by providing bank accounts or credentials.12

MHA emphasized the need for a strong deterrent approach, stating, “If a deterrent approach is not taken, Singapore's scam and youth offending situation could deteriorate.” The proposed Bill aims to ensure that courts consider reformative training or imprisonment as primary options for offenders aged 21 and below, unless exceptional circumstances arise.
The High Court's recent judgment, which allowed probation for some young offenders, has been criticized by MHA as inconsistent with the intention to impose deterrent sentences. The Bill asserts that the High Court's decision will not bind future cases, reinforcing the need for a robust response to the ongoing scam epidemic, which sees an average of 90 scam reports daily resulting in losses of $2 million in the first half of 2026.
“The Bill follows a High Court ruling that favored probation for young offenders, which MHA says contradicts Parliament's deterrence intent. In 2025, police investigated over 1,000 youths in scam cases, and youth cheating offences rose 37% from 814 to 1,114.”