Kevin ReddingtonLindsay ClancyWilliam SullivanPlymouth County District Attorney's Office

Lindsay Clancy jury heads back into deliberations after twice reporting deadlock; defense attorney calls case a 'tragedy'

The jury in Lindsay Clancy's murder trial has entered a sixth day of deliberations after reporting deadlock twice. Clancy, charged with three counts of first-degree murder, pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity, while her defense attorney described the case as a 'tragedy.'

Boston.com Boston.com3 September 2026 · 13:30 UTC
CuriousCats Full Story

The jury in Lindsay Clancy's murder trial has been deliberating for over 30 hours across five days, struggling to reach a unanimous verdict.23

Judge William Sullivan has instructed jurors with the Tuey-Rodriguez charge, urging them to reach a verdict if possible.

If they remain deadlocked, a mistrial may be declared, allowing the Plymouth County District Attorney's Office to consider a retrial.1

Clancy, 36, faces three counts of first-degree murder for the deaths of her children, aged 5, 3, and 8 months, which she admits to committing but claims was due to an insanity defense.

Defense attorney Kevin Reddington stated, “I don’t think this case is a victory, period. It’s a tragedy,” emphasizing the jury's hard work despite the challenges.

Prosecutors argue Clancy was aware of her actions despite her mental health struggles, while her defense claims she was suffering from auditory hallucinations.

If found not guilty by reason of insanity, Clancy may still face commitment to a mental health facility rather than freedom.

Clancy remains paralyzed after a suicide attempt following the incident and has been in a state-run hospital since January 2023.

Key Insight
“If the jury remains deadlocked, Judge Sullivan could declare a mistrial, allowing the Plymouth County District Attorney's Office to decide on a retrial. Defense attorney Kevin Reddington praised the jury's effort over about 30 hours, saying he wouldn't view a hung jury as a win.”
CuriousCats studied:
1
Boston.comBoston.com
“Jurors in ’s murder trial will enter a sixth day of deliberations Thursday after reporting twice now that they have been unable to reach a unanimous verdict.”
Boston.com →
Ask CuriousCats
Who is Lindsay Clancy?
What are the charges against her?
Why did the jury report a deadlock?
Are other trials facing similar deadlocks?
How does this case compare to previous high-profile trials?
CuriousCats STORYARC
EARLIER IN THE STORY:
Lindsay Clancy jury reports deadlock during deliberations; judge urges reconsideration as mistrial risk grows
ABC7 ChicagoABC7 Chicago
Lindsay Clancy jury reports deadlock during deliberations; judge urges reconsideration as mistrial risk grows

The deadlocked jury in the Lindsay Clancy trial was expected to keep trying to reach a verdict Thursday and avoid a mistrial after telling the judge twice that they can't agree whether the Massachusetts mother is criminally responsible for killing her three children.

Courtroom ImpasseDeliberations ContinueHung Jury
2026-09-03
TL;DR by CuriousCats.ai
  • The jury has reported a deadlock during deliberations in the Lindsay Clancy trial, raising concerns about a potential mistrial.
  • Judge William Sullivan explained to the courtroom that jurors were at an impasse, indicating a growing chance of a hung jury and the trial ending without a resolution.
  • Sullivan urged jurors to reconsider their positions and to seriously consider opposing views, emphasizing that no one knows if another jury would be more competent.
  • If the jury cannot agree on a verdict, the judge could declare a mistrial, leading prosecutors to decide whether to retry Clancy, drop the charges, or negotiate a plea deal.
  • If the jury finds Clancy criminally responsible for her actions, she could be convicted of either murder or manslaughter.
  • In the event of an acquittal, a judge could still confine her to a mental health facility if deemed a danger to the public.
CNN
Lindsay Clancy jury deliberates for sixth day after twice reporting deadlock; judge read Tuey-Rodriguez instructions, mistrial possible if impasse persists

The jury in the Lindsay Clancy trial is deliberating for a sixth day after twice telling the judge they could not reach a unanimous verdict.

Judge SullivanJury ImpasseMistrial Possibility
2026-09-03
TL;DR by CuriousCats.ai
  • The jury in the Lindsay Clancy trial is deliberating for a sixth day after twice telling the judge they could not reach a unanimous verdict.
  • The judge read the Tuey-Rodriguez instructions, a special final instruction, after the jury reported deadlock for the second time.
  • The jury sent notes on Tuesday and Wednesday stating they were unable to reach a unanimous decision, and the judge instructed them to continue deliberating.
  • If the jury remains deadlocked, the judge will likely declare a mistrial, and the prosecution would state its intent to retry, with Clancy returned to Tewksbury Hospital held without bail.
Jury in Lindsay Clancy trial returns for potential final day of deliberations after second deadlock; judge urges continued talks
YahooYahoo
Jury in Lindsay Clancy trial returns for potential final day of deliberations after second deadlock; judge urges continued talks

The jury in the Lindsay Clancy trial returns to court Thursday morning for what could be its final day of deliberations after a second deadlock.

Deliberations ContinueJury DeadlockJury Instruction
2026-09-03
TL;DR by CuriousCats.ai
  • The jury returns to court Thursday morning for what could be its final day of deliberations after reporting a second deadlock.
  • Jurors have now spent roughly 30 hours over five days reviewing evidence and testimony in one of Massachusetts' most closely watched criminal cases.
  • On Wednesday afternoon, the jury informed Plymouth Superior Court Judge William Sullivan of a second deadlock.
  • Judge Sullivan gave a Tuey-Rodriguez instruction, urging jurors to continue deliberating and consider one another's views.
  • Judge Sullivan dismissed jurors for the day shortly after 4 p.m. Wednesday and instructed them to return Thursday morning.
  • The central issue facing jurors is whether Clancy was criminally responsible for her actions.
CuriousCats
RELATED COVERAGE:
Lindsay Clancy's lawyer says she can't handle another trial; jury remains unable to reach unanimous verdict
The Hill🇺🇸2 September 2026 · 22:15 UTC
Lindsay Clancy's lawyer says she can't handle another trial; jury remains unable to reach unanimous verdict

During the trial, Clancy showed a flat affect and sadness, and proceedings were repeatedly paused because she became overwhelmed. If the jury still can't agree, prosecutors and the defense could strike a plea deal instead of another full trial, or a future trial could be restructured.

Deadlocked jury in Lindsay Clancy trial returns for sixth day of deliberation; judge gives 'dynamite charge' after twice failing to agree on criminal responsibility
AP News🇺🇸3 September 2026 · 11:38 UTC
Deadlocked jury in Lindsay Clancy trial returns for sixth day of deliberation; judge gives 'dynamite charge' after twice failing to agree on criminal responsibility

The jury twice reported an impasse, prompting Judge William Sullivan to issue a 'dynamite charge' urging them to reconsider. If no verdict is reached, a mistrial will be declared, and prosecutors will decide whether to retry Clancy or offer a plea deal.

Lindsay Clancy jury dismissed for the day after reporting impasse; deliberations continue in triple-murder trial
MassLive.com🇺🇸1 September 2026 · 20:19 UTC
Lindsay Clancy jury dismissed for the day after reporting impasse; deliberations continue in triple-murder trial

Jurors have deliberated about 23 hours over four days, with more than 80 witnesses and 300 exhibits presented. Clancy, 36, faces three counts of first-degree murder in the strangling deaths of her children, with options including second-degree murder or manslaughter.

Lindsay Clancy jury reports deadlock for second time as deliberations stretch into fifth day; judge issues Tuey-Rodriguez charge
🇺🇸3 September 2026 · 07:50 UTC
Lindsay Clancy jury reports deadlock for second time as deliberations stretch into fifth day; judge issues Tuey-Rodriguez charge

Legal experts say the nearly 30 hours of deliberation do not predict a verdict, with Randall Kessler noting juries at an impasse often reach a verdict as holdouts give ground. The case hinges on whether Clancy's postpartum psychosis defense overcomes three counts of first-degree murder in the 2023 deaths of her children.

Jury in Lindsay Clancy murder trial deadlocks twice; Judge William Sullivan issues Tuey-Rodriguez 'dynamite charge' to push deliberations
WCVB🇺🇸3 September 2026 · 04:05 UTC
Jury in Lindsay Clancy murder trial deadlocks twice; Judge William Sullivan issues Tuey-Rodriguez 'dynamite charge' to push deliberations

The instruction reminds jurors of their duty and the Commonwealth's burden to prove every element beyond a reasonable doubt, urging them to respect each other's opinions. If the deadlock persists, a mistrial could be declared, as in Read's first trial, leaving retrial to prosecutors.

Lindsay Clancy jury reports deadlock for second time after 28 hours of deliberations; judge issues dynamite charge urging them to continue
WBUR🇺🇸2 September 2026 · 22:58 UTC
Lindsay Clancy jury reports deadlock for second time after 28 hours of deliberations; judge issues dynamite charge urging them to continue

The jury, nine women and three men, has deliberated about 29.5 hours over five days. If they remain deadlocked, the judge may declare a mistrial, and Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy Cruz would decide whether to retry the case.

Jury in Lindsay Clancy murder trial gets 'dynamite charge' after continued deadlock; legal analyst breaks down possible verdicts
WJAR🇺🇸2 September 2026 · 20:16 UTC
Jury in Lindsay Clancy murder trial gets 'dynamite charge' after continued deadlock; legal analyst breaks down possible verdicts

Retired judge Jim Barretto said the Tuey-Rodriguez instruction can be given only once more; if deadlock persists, a mistrial would be declared, leaving the DA to decide on a second trial. Judge Sullivan also reminded all of an order and statute being enforced after an arrest outside court.

Lindsay Clancy jury reports deadlock for second time; judge issues Tuey-Rodriguez charge, warns mistrial possible if hung jury persists
KOMO🇺🇸2 September 2026 · 23:24 UTC
Lindsay Clancy jury reports deadlock for second time; judge issues Tuey-Rodriguez charge, warns mistrial possible if hung jury persists

Judge William F. Sullivan questioned all 12 jurors and 6 alternates individually after a jury intimidation incident led to the arrest of 56-year-old Dawn Light. If the deadlock continues, a mistrial will be declared, leaving the case unresolved.

Lindsay Clancy jury deadlocked for second day; judge reads Tuey-Rodriguez instructions, deliberations to continue Thursday
🇺🇸2 September 2026 · 21:04 UTC
Lindsay Clancy jury deadlocked for second day; judge reads Tuey-Rodriguez instructions, deliberations to continue Thursday

Judge William Sullivan read the Tuey-Rodriguez instructions, urging jurors to reconsider opposing views and return a verdict if they can do so conscientiously. If the jury remains deadlocked, a mistrial could be declared, likely leading to a retrial of the case.

Lindsay Clancy jury deadlocked for second time as judge questions panel about woman accused of filming them; deliberations enter Day 5
The New York Times🇺🇸2 September 2026 · 18:38 UTC
Lindsay Clancy jury deadlocked for second time as judge questions panel about woman accused of filming them; deliberations enter Day 5

The woman, Dawn Light, 56, was charged with intimidation of a witness and released without bail, but ordered to stay away from court and jurors. If the jury remains deadlocked, the judge could declare a mistrial, forcing prosecutors to decide whether to retry Clancy or negotiate a plea.

Get your CIA-level briefing,
in real time.
CuriousCats monitors the internet every minute for you and brings you the most personalized brief of videos, social media posts, news and more.
Download the App
Liked the depth here?
Get the full internet briefed for you any time of the day.
Get CuriousCats