- A celebrity has lost a fight to block the publication of allegations that he abused his status to exploit young women for sex.
- The man used an 'unprecedented' argument that he would commit suicide if the Guardian and ITN reported claims he used his power and status to engage in 'inappropriate and exploitative sexual activities' with a large number of young women.
- Mr Justice Nicklin said the evidence did not 'establish that suicide is inevitable'.
- In written submissions, the judge said: 'The celebrity has repeatedly said that he intends to take his own life if publication occurs.' Those statements must be taken seriously, particularly because of his previous behaviour. They do not, however, establish that suicide is inevitable or that treatment cannot reduce the risk.
- The judge found that, although the proposed publication of the claims was a 'powerful trigger', they were not the sole cause of the man’s psychiatric condition or suicidality.
- He added that the likelihood of suicide could be reduced through in-patient psychiatric care, and publication while the man was in hospital would be 'significantly safer'.
- In a judgment on Tuesday at the High Court, Nicklin also said: 'The injunction would not treat the claimant’s underlying psychiatric condition' or eliminate his elevated baseline risk.
- NHS psychiatric services were enough to fulfil the state’s obligation to protect the celebrity’s life, he added, and there was therefore no basis to silence the media.
A celebrity has lost a High Court battle to block allegations of sexual exploitation linked to his status, with Mr Justice Nicklin ruling against the man's unprecedented suicide argument. The judge emphasized that the evidence presented did not prove that suicide was inevitable.
The celebrity claimed he would take his own life if the allegations were published, stating, “Those statements must be taken seriously, particularly because of his previous behaviour.” However, the judge noted that these claims did not establish an unavoidable risk of suicide or that treatment options were ineffective.
In his judgment, Nicklin remarked that while the proposed publication could act as a “powerful trigger” for the man's psychiatric condition, it was not the sole cause of his suicidality. He suggested that in-patient psychiatric care could significantly reduce the risk of suicide, indicating that publication during hospitalization would be “significantly safer.”6
Furthermore, the judge stated that the injunction sought by the celebrity would not address his underlying psychiatric issues or eliminate his elevated risk. He concluded that NHS psychiatric services were sufficient to meet the state's obligation to protect the celebrity's life, thus providing no grounds to silence the media.
“Mr Justice Nicklin found the 'unprecedented' suicide threat did not make suicide inevitable, citing in-patient psychiatric care as a safer alternative. The judge also stated the injunction would not treat the celebrity's underlying condition or eliminate his elevated baseline risk.”









